Sometimes Visual Is Not Enough

Start Concrete To Build Spatial Reasoning Skills

TITM - Sometimes visual is not enough

Recently, I shared out the following set of visual prompts to elicit an understanding of area with rectangles on my other site, MathIsVisual.com:

Area of a Rectangle - Visual Prompt 1 SHORT Notice Wonder AND Estimate GIF

You can access the set of 4 visual prompts here.

While this series of visual prompts has been a hit in many classrooms, something that is easy to forget is that while making math visual is a great way to lower the floor instead of rushing to symbols, rules, and algorithms, that floor is not low enough for learners who are still developing their spatial reasoning skills such as visualization and abstraction.

I got to get a taste of this in a grade 3 classroom today while learning with a group of amazing teachers in my district where we used this particular task to attempt to make a connection from multiplication where the Hot Chocolate Task was used recently to introduce the idea of the array to area of a rectangle.

As many know, I’m a huge advocate of using concreteness fading, concrete-representational-abstract (CRA), or Experiential, Language, Pictorial, Symbolic (ELPS) for teaching mathematics concepts, however it is easy to make assumptions that students are ready for that visual/pictorial stage when in fact, they are still in need of the concrete. However, as a group of educators and I planned how we were going to facilitate this lesson prior to going into the classroom, we all felt that students were going to be fine to use the visual prompts in order to help them re-create a model of the area situation with square tiles. However, something we didn’t anticipate was the difficulty students would have with how a certain level of abstraction would be necessary to realize that the two squares on the screen were a scaled up version of the model they would be recreating with square tiles.

We quickly saw students doing this:

Sometimes visual is not enough - need for concrete and less abstraction - Students measuring the screen copy

It was clear that they were struggling to narrow down what unit of measure they would be using to measure the large blue square. For many students, it appeared as though they were trying to determine how many concrete square tiles they would need in order to cover the small orange square on the screen and had almost forgotten about the blue square completely. For others, their plan was clearly to first determine how many square tiles were required to cover the blue square and then proceed to iterate that “chunk” or “unit” of square tiles over the blue square.

As this was taking place, I acted on my feet and found some scrap paper to help…

Sometimes visual is not enough - square and rectangle cut outs copy

Initially, I just cut out squares that were scaled appropriately for the square tiles and then the rectangles for the second visual prompt we would be doing later on in the lesson. We then simply held up 1 square tile and 1 of the square cut-outs and said:

You see this orange square on the screen? That’s like this square tile right here.
You see the blue square on the screen? That’s like this paper square right here.
Can you use this to help you?

After that, students were off to the races and quickly determined the number of squares to be 25 square tiles.

We then worked on visual prompt #3 from the same MathIsVisual post where students were challenged with this visual prompt:

Math Is Visual - Area of a Rectangle Visual Prompts.082 visual prompt 3

Here’s some of what we saw and heard:

Sometimes concrete is not enough - students arranging a row of 4 square tiles copy

You’ll often hear me say that “we should to avoid the rush to the algorithm”, but maybe I need to start becoming more vocal about avoiding the rush to the visual.

So while I’m a big fan of making math visual, because Math IS Visual, we must not forget about the extremely important starting point: the concrete stage.


Memorization vs. Automaticity

What's The Difference?

Find out by downloading the 5-Page Printable Memorization vs. Automaticity Cheat Sheet to learn more! A ton of great learning to be had with this printable & sharable E-Book!


Share With Your Learning Community:



About Kyle Pearce

I’m Kyle Pearce and I am a former high school math teacher. I’m now the K-12 Mathematics Consultant with the Greater Essex County District School Board, where I uncover creative ways to spark curiosity and fuel sense making in mathematics. Read more.


Read More From The Blog




Not What You're Looking For?

Search By Criteria:

Subscribe