iPad PDF Annotation Apps; Do You Get What You Pay For?

As I start to get my 1:1 iPad classroom running smoothly, I have only installed and tested apps which are free in the App  Store.  Since there are thousands of free apps popping up all the time, it seems logical that many may not be very well developed.  Heck, if it’s free, who’s going to complain.  Right?  Unfortunately, when your lesson surrounds the use of a particular app, it can be very upsetting.

The Three Contenders

The three free PDF annotation apps I downloaded to test on the iPads were pdf-notes 2.0.0, neu.Annotate & Noterize. 

All three programs seem very user friendly at first glance.  pdf-notes appeared to have the most features, including hand gestures which allowed you to change between writing tools, zoom in quick and easily without having to tap away from a pen tool, and many more.  After the first day of experimentation with my class, we attempted to flatten a PDF and save it to Dropbox and all students experienced a crash of the app.  Unsure what causes the crash exactly, but it clearly had to do with exporting to Dropbox; a key component for the students.  Still trying to figure this one out, as it’d be a shame to abandon this app due to the Dropbox issue.

Noterize, another free annotation app, immediately turns me off because of the pixelated appearance of any pen used on the PDF.  It seems as though any writing comes through in a very low-resolution, which makes the document look messy and old.  Some may think this is only one small inconvenience, but I’d rather move on to find a better app if at all possible.

neu.Annotate PDF seemed like the best alternative to pdf-notes.  Not as many features, but very clean looking and all of the essential features were present.  Exporting to Dropbox was also an option, which was a requirement for my students.  After testing this app a few times in the classroom, some students were experiencing errors when trying to save their PDF.  The error claimed that there was not enough memory available to do so.  Clearly, the working memory in the iPad could not handle the demands of the app and/or the amount of annotations which were being made on the PDF file.

As I continue to search for the perfect free annotation app for iPad 2, I wonder if the old saying is true… You Get What You Pay For…

In my case, paying nothing has equated to receiving the same…

Check Out Other Recent Posts:

2 comments on “iPad PDF Annotation Apps; Do You Get What You Pay For?

  1. M says:

    Interesting to hear about how the apps are used and in a specific location.
    i have tried free and paid for apps and it does seem that you do indeed get what you pay for
    in fact i got so fed up with the poor quality of some of the freebies i took a risk and purchased a pdf app called writepdf
    seeing that you were trying to access dropbox from pdf notes and experiencing crashes, i can honestly say that i have had no problems with writepdf as it accesses dropbox successfully. May be worth buying? Oh go on! ?Looking forward to more of your posts!

    • Kyle Pearce Mr. Pearce says:

      Hi M:
      You know, I must say that new.annotate is just awesome. They now only have a paid version for $0.99 but it is well worth it.

      I often teach via apple tv and my iPad using that app as my “whiteboard” overtop PDF files or a blank slate.

      Awesome stuff! Thanks for the comment!

What do you think? Give your say!


Privacy Policy | Sitemap

%d bloggers like this: